Anxiety and divergent thinking

Some people often see connections and possibilities others miss—a gift of divergent thinking. But what happens when that creativity turns inward, fueling not solutions, but spirals of worry and self-doubt? What is divergent thinking? Divergent thinking is the ability to generate multiple, creative ideas or solutions. It’s what helps neurodivergent individuals think outside the box, …

Some people often see connections and possibilities others miss—a gift of divergent thinking. But what happens when that creativity turns inward, fueling not solutions, but spirals of worry and self-doubt?

What is divergent thinking?

Divergent thinking is the ability to generate multiple, creative ideas or solutions. It’s what helps neurodivergent individuals think outside the box, innovate, and solve complex problems.

For many, it’s a powerful asset: it drives innovation, fuels imagination, and allows for out-of-the-box problem-solving. Divergent thinkers often excel in areas like brainstorming, artistic expression, or navigating complex situations.

Sound great! What is the problem, then?

Unfortunately, the same creativity that generates innovative solutions can also amplify anxiety. Divergent thinkers, particularly those who are neurodivergent, might not just think about one thing going wrong—they might envision all the ways things could go wrong. In vivid, overwhelming detail.

This constant flow of ideas can spiral into overthinking, where the “what-ifs” multiply uncontrollably. An imagined scenario isn’t just a fleeting thought—it can transform into an elaborate mental narrative filled with worst-case outcomes.

Moreover, this ability to imagine endless possibilities can foster feelings of hopelessness, especially when those creative visions focus on failure or unattainable perfection. What starts as problem-solving can quickly morph into problem creating.

The Exhaustion of an Overactive Mind

For neurodivergent individuals, divergent thinking often doesn’t have an off switch. The brain is constantly cycling through scenarios, possibilities, and creative ideas. This mental activity, when unchecked, can lead to:

Mental Exhaustion: The brain gets no rest from the stream of thoughts, leading to burnout.

Decision Paralysis: Too many ideas and contingencies can make it hard to choose a path forward, leaving people stuck in limbo.

Chronic Overwhelm: Without a productive outlet, these thoughts build up, exacerbating anxiety and depression.

Examples of Divergent Thinking Turned Inward

ADHD and Catastrophizing: Someone with ADHD might obsessively brainstorm worst-case scenarios before a presentation. Instead of focusing on the content, they envision each potential mishap—forgetting their notes, the audience laughing, or even tripping on stage. These spirals become increasingly catastrophic, stealing focus and confidence.

Autism and Anticipation Overload: An autistic individual might rely on their pattern-recognition skills to anticipate problems. While this can be a strength, it can also lead to an overwhelming list of contingencies. They mentally prepare for every possible deviation, leaving little energy for actually engaging with the task at hand.

So this is just my brain and there is nothing I can do?

While the challenges of divergent thinking can feel overwhelming, it’s important to remember that the same creativity that fuels worry and self-doubt is also a source of resilience, innovation, and growth. Divergent thinkers have a rare gift: the ability to reframe challenges, see opportunities others overlook, and imagine brighter futures—not just for themselves, but for the world around them.

The key lies in learning to channel this incredible mental energy in ways that serve us, rather than drain us. There is a way, we just need to get creative about it. Because typical advice does not always for us.

In the next article, I’ll explore practical strategies to harness divergent thinking as a tool for empowerment and well-being. But for now, take heart: the vivid, imaginative mind that sometimes feels like your greatest challenge isn’t your enemy. With patience and tools designed for neurodivergent thinkers, you can not only make peace with your mind but turn it into your greatest ally—your most loyal and supportive friend.